Mel always delivers on my vision!! And her cupcakes are delicious to boot! Highly recommend
— Emily F.

Product List & Pricing

Please note that each order is custom-made and therefore aside from standard orders, pricing may vary. Please inquire here about event-specific cakes (bridal and baby showers, gender reveals, birthdays, office parties, etc) to determine the best size/flavor combination for your occasion.

Delivery: free to Carmel locations. Surrounding Indy areas $20/order (multiple drop-off specials available. Contact Mel for more info).


Cake Varieties (to name just a few…)

These are just a sample of what Mel can make. Colors, flavors and decor may vary according to your needs. (Note: many of these can be translated into cupcakes. Chat with Mel for more info.)

  • Chocoholic’s Dream

    • Chocolate layers, filled with rich chocolate fudge buttercream and chocolate ganache. Piped with chocolate roses and ganache drip. 6” cake: $65; 8” cake: $80

  • Red Velvet Oh Yeah

    • Mmmm, red velvet. Need I say more? Okay then: red velvet cake with luscious cream cheese buttercream frosting. 6” cake: $60; 8” cake: $75

  • Lemon Raspberry Layer Cake

    • Vanilla or lemon cake, filled with lemon curd and frosted with Swiss Meringue raspberry buttercream. Your choice or rosettes, sprinkles or buttercream flowers. 6”cake: $65; 8” cake: $80

  • Rosette Cake

    • Your choice of chocolate, vanilla or lemon cake, with chocolate, vanilla or lemon buttercream layers. Piped with beautiful rosettes in color of your choice. 4” cake: $27; 6” cake: $55; 8” cake: $70

  • Very Berry Cake

    • Vanilla cake or lemon cake with a berry coulis of your choice (strawberry, raspberry, blueberry), piped with vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream and piped with buttercream flowers or fresh berries (when in season). 6” cake: $60; 8” cake: $80.

  • Chocolate Hazelnut

    • Chocolate cake with house-made hazelnut spread buttercream filling, frosted with chocolate buttercream and piped with chocolate buttercream roses or chocolate dipped hazelnuts. 6” cake: $65; 8” cake: $85

  • Caramel Lover’s Delight

    • Browned butter vanilla cake filled with salted caramel and Swiss Meringue buttercream, and topped with more salted caramel drizzle. 6” cake: $55; 8” cake: $70

  • Spiced Vanilla n’ Chocolate

    • Spiced vanilla cake, with chocolate Swiss Meringue buttercream and spiced Mexican chocolate ganache filling and drizzle. 6” cake: $60; 8” cake: $75

  • Gender Reveal Cakes

    • Your secret is safe with us!! Your choice of vanilla, chocolate, lemon or berry cake, filled with pink or blue buttercream, and frosted with gender-neutral buttercream and sprinkles. 6” cake: $55; 8” cake: $70

  • Milestone Moments

    • Your choice of cake flavor: vanilla, chocolate, lemon, berry, brown butter or caramel, with complementing buttercream flavor, decorated with piped buttercream and a shower of sprinkles. Celebrate your momentous achievement the sweet way! 6” cake: $55; 8” cake: $70

  • Spiced Pumpkin

    • Spiced pumpkin cake with layers of cream cheese filling, frosted “naked” (scandalous!) and topped with caramelized spiced pecans. 6” cake: $55; 8” cake: $70

  • Tiramisu Cake

    • Vanilla sponge cake soaked with a mixture of coffee and Kahlua, filled with layers of creamy mascarpone buttercream, frosted “naked” with vanilla buttercream and topped with cocoa powder and chocolate covered espresso beans. 6” cake: $60; 8” cake: $75

  • Rainbow Cake

    • Rainbow vanilla cake, frosted with the colors of the rainbow to make anyone’s special day that much more unique. 6” cake: $60; 8” cake: $75

  • “Pinata” Cake

    • Really, this cake is perfect to fill with whatever you want…sprinkles, a hidden surprise (engagement ring anyone?), bubblegum…whatever you’re thinking, we can work on it together! 6” cake: $65; 8” cake: $80


Flowers…ON a cupcake.  That’s like two gifts in one!  ($39/dozen)

Flowers…ON a cupcake. That’s like two gifts in one! ($39/dozen)

Peanut Butter Cup Swirl ($39/dozen)

Peanut Butter Cup Swirl ($39/dozen)

With so many sprinkle and color varieties, the options are endless!

With so many sprinkle and color varieties, the options are endless!

Chocolate and vanilla cupcakes with piped buttercream frosting. ($39/dozen)

Chocolate and vanilla cupcakes with piped buttercream frosting. ($39/dozen)

So. Much. CHOCOLATE GOODNESS! ($39/dozen)

So. Much. CHOCOLATE GOODNESS! ($39/dozen)

Pop-By Gift Boxes for your clients are a perfect way to say “Thank You!” ($10/box (10 box minimum))

Pop-By Gift Boxes for your clients are a perfect way to say “Thank You!” ($10/box (10 box minimum))

With a “Chef’s Assortment”, you can get a little taste of everything! ($39/dozen)

With a “Chef’s Assortment”, you can get a little taste of everything! ($39/dozen)

Cupcakes available for ALL seasons and holidays!

Cupcakes available for ALL seasons and holidays!

Variation of Chocoholic’s Dream ($65-$80)

Variation of Chocoholic’s Dream ($65-$80)

Red Velvet in all its glory. ($30-$75)

Red Velvet in all its glory. ($30-$75)

Vanilla Raspberry Layer Cake with Spring Flowers ($65-$80)

Vanilla Raspberry Layer Cake with Spring Flowers ($65-$80)

Rosette Cake ($27-$70)

Rosette Cake ($27-$70)

Chocolate/Hazelnut with piped Chocolate Buttercream Roses. ($65-80)

Chocolate/Hazelnut with piped Chocolate Buttercream Roses. ($65-80)

Caramel Lovers Delight ($55-$70)

Caramel Lovers Delight ($55-$70)

Vanilla Cake with Lemon Curd Filling and Raspberry Buttercream. ($65-$80)

Vanilla Cake with Lemon Curd Filling and Raspberry Buttercream. ($65-$80)

Vanilla Spice Cake with Mexican Chocolate Ganache & Chocolate Buttercream ($65-$80)

Vanilla Spice Cake with Mexican Chocolate Ganache & Chocolate Buttercream ($65-$80)

Gender Reveal Cakes ($55-$70)

Gender Reveal Cakes ($55-$70)

Celebrate momentous moments with a cake as sweet as your loved one.

Celebrate momentous moments with a cake as sweet as your loved one.

Spiced pumpkin cake ($55-$70)

Spiced pumpkin cake ($55-$70)

Tiramisu Cake ($60-$75)

Tiramisu Cake ($60-$75)

A rainbow of flavor! ($60-$75)

A rainbow of flavor! ($60-$75)

This “pinata” cake is perfect for a surprise proposal! ($65-$80)

This “pinata” cake is perfect for a surprise proposal! ($65-$80)